Jump to content
Hockey Wilderness
  • Dean Evason's Firing Was About More Than Dean Evason


    Image courtesy of Brace Hemmelgam-USA Today Sports
    Tony Abbott

    It's shocking how fast things turned, but it's not tough to see why the Minnesota Wild dismissed head coach Dean Evason and assistant coach Bob Woods on Monday afternoon. After dropping their seventh game in a row, a 4-1 clunker to the Detroit Red Wings, Minnesota now sits at 30th in the league, with just two points separating them from the 31st-place Chicago Blackhawks and four from the dead-last San Jose Sharks.

    The Wild are reportedly hiring John Hynes and going for a turnaround, but being seven points out of a playoff spot after Thanksgiving makes the road ahead difficult, even with a new voice. Worse yet, the Wild are a whopping 12 points from third place in the Central Division. That means that if the Wild do go on a run starting tomorrow night, they can only (realistically) claim a Wild Card spot. In that case, they'd face a first-round date with a Western Conference heavyweight like the Stars, Colorado Avalanche, Vegas Golden Knights, or Los Angeles Kings.

    "Why bother?" might well be the attitude of a Wild fan base that has seen better versions of this core do worse in the first round of the playoffs. Why not let this team sink? Especially with a prize like Macklin Celebrini at the end of the rainbow for one lucky bad team. So why are the Wild looking to salvage the season?

    If any team would get a pass for taking a step back, it would be this Wild team. They're buckling under nearly $15 million in buyout penalties, severely restricting their team-building ability. While Evason's seat got too hot for him to stay on as coach, general manager Bill Guerin's seat is firmly entrenched.

    The Wild just promoted Guerin to President of Hockey Operations this past offseason and gave him an extension. With the exception of Paul Fenton's truly bizarre 14-month run, owner Mr. Craig Leipold has shown tremendous long-term faith in general managers. David Poile stood as GM for Mr. Leipold's entire run as owner of the Nashville Predators. Chuck Fletcher held his post for nearly a decade, even with little playoff success to show for it.

    This is all to say that if Guerin does something drastic to save the Wild's season in the next short while, it's not about self-preservation. If it's not about self-preservation, though, what is it about?

    Two words: Number ninety-seven.

    What separates the Wild from a rebuilding team? All due respect to remarkably solid players like Jared Spurgeon, Jonas Brodin, and Joel Eriksson Ek, but Kirill Kaprizov is that difference. Despite his well-documented struggles this season and not quite looking like himself, Kaprizov is still an in-his-prime superstar. Getting him back on track represents the only hope of getting the Wild back to their winning ways and is also the biggest reason to wish for them to do so.

    This season can't be fun for Kaprizov. Say what you will about what they've done when his Wild get to the playoffs, but all Kaprizov knows is winning. During his first three seasons in Minnesota, the Wild registered a points percentage of .661, or an average of 108 points per 82 games. Dating back to his KHL days, Kaprizov hasn't missed a postseason since 2015-16, when the 18-year-old was playing for his hometown Mettallurg Novokuznetsk. 

    Unfortunately, this season is probably the worst time for the Wild to collapse, and it's because of Kaprizov. The State of Hockey is months away from seeing a large amount of power fall into Kaprizov's hands. Kaprizov's No-Move Clause will kick in at the start of the new league year (July 1). Before that point, Minnesota has complete control over what they do with his contract. After July 1, Kaprizov gets the final say.

    This means that if, say, the Wild miss the playoffs and Kaprizov becomes unhappy with the situation, he can not only request a trade but dictate which suitors can trade for him. There is potential for him to not only engineer a way out but also depress the market for his services by targeting a single destination.

    To be clear, we have no insight into Kaprizov's mindset or willingness to stay in Minnesota long-term. We aren't fear-mongering. It's simply a reality that Minnesota has to account for and hedge against, which they've (likely) been doing since this summer. You can read this summer's extensions to linemates Mats Zuccarello and Ryan Hartman as efforts to keep Kaprizov happy. In naming him an alternate captain, the Wild seemed to attempt to solidify his feeling of ownership over this team.

    Making the playoffs is part of that project, even if it means having to offer Evason up as a sacrificial lamb. It's important to give a taste of success to Kaprizov during these dead cap years in tandem with selling him on the team's emerging prospect base. Maybe Kaprizov is looking forward to the team's future to the point where he can be patient without short-term success. But is Guerin going to risk it if he can help it? The answer is obviously "no."

    It's easy to say that the Wild's long-term interests are best served with the team staying the course and letting what happens happens. That might mean turning it around for a playoff run, it may include the Wild continuing their Playing Like A Weenie For Celebrini campaign. Still, Guerin is 100% right to fear a potential Kaprizov departure. The biggest reason anyone's talked about the team for the past three years is because of the star power he commands. He's been the engine of Minnesota's recent successes. Without him, the long-term future of the team gets muddied.

    Yes, the emergence of Matt Boldy (present struggles notwithstanding), Marco Rossi, and Brock Faber are extremely encouraging. So is having Jesper Wallstedt, Danila Yurov, and Riley Heidt emerging as star prospects behind them. But no one can count on their prospect pool regularly churning out stars. Even so, if all those prospects become impact players, they're still better off with Kaprizov anchoring and elevating the bunch.

    As fruitless as making the playoffs seems as a goal, the point is that the Wild and Guerin almost certainly need Kaprizov for long-term viability. There aren't many paths to being better in a Kaprizov-less future. And there's no upside for Guerin to be the person who let Kaprizov and Kevin Fiala get away in the span of three years. If you're wondering why the Wild would bother to try getting back on track, all you have to do is tap into your existential dread at the thought of what happens after a lost season.

    This isn't to say Evason didn't have his own problems leading to his dismissal. He couldn't get Kaprizov or Boldy going offensively this season, his team's defensive structure and penalty kill collapsed, and this compounded with wretched goaltending. Still, it's easy to argue that the winningest coach in team history (.639 career points percentage) got a raw deal.

    Maybe he did. But at the end of the day, this wasn't about him or anything he did. It was about the chips the Wild had already pushed into the middle to make the playoffs this year. More importantly, it was about the urgency to go further into "all-in" territory for a postseason berth in a bid to solidify Kaprizov's future with the team. Agree with it or not, the Wild were always going to head down this path. We'll now see if it works.

    Think you could write a story like this? Hockey Wilderness wants you to develop your voice, find an audience, and we'll pay you to do it. Just fill out this form.

    • Like 5

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    I just can't imagine that this is all about #97. I think he genuinely likes it in MN. We are a mid market team that has fans like a large market team. Kaprizov gets to stay somewhat hidden (he doesn't like to do interviews), but still enjoy the big crowds. This place is perfect for him.....if we're winning.

    If the rumor of John Hynes is correct, has Hynes won in the postseason? And, as I look across the interwebs to look it up, indeed, Hynes is the guy. 

    Here is what I found:

    Quote

    In 602 NHL games over nine seasons with the Devils and Predators, Hynes is 284-255-63 (.524 points percentage) with a 4-15 playoff record and no rounds won.

    At the time of Evason's hiring, this was actually a better postseason record than he had.

    Now, looking closer at his record, this will be the best roster Hynes has had. He previously coached in NJ and Nashville. The good news is that the above statistics are only for the NHL. Evason's record also included the A where Hynes has seen success in the postseason. 

    He is also coming from under the Penguins coaching tree having been part of their A franchise. I would have to believe that he overlapped with Guerin during this time, and it appears that Hynes also prefers the gritty play. 

    • Like 2
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    3 minutes ago, joebou15 said:

    Makes you think about how Tim Army was scapegoated in Iowa and Brett McLean is struggling there too. Methinks Guerin is not great at evaluating coaches.

    I realize Brett McLean is struggling there, but to be perfectly blunt, his D corps has been all very young, especially when the leader of the group, Dakota Mermis was up with the big club. That will cause anyone to struggle, and if you look at McIntyre's line, I believe that's where the struggle is. 

    Hopefully John Hynes believes in practicing. I'd think the Wild will be doing a lot of it!

    • Like 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Good job wild making some desperately needed changes! Good luck to the new head coach. John I believe. I definitely will give him time to install his systems and coaching style. Hope it works for him. 
         However IMO his tenure will be short. I believe this team will eat coaches till the extensions play out.  Taking the tool of accountability away from the coach with no move clause means the players now run the show. Bill and the coach are at the mercy of the players. They don’t run anything the players do. So I expect the players will run him out of town as well . Just a matter of time. 
        If the coach is HYNES  I wish him well. He was coach of Nashville last year. They were built like we are now. Lots of vets on bad contracts. From the little I paid attention to preds, it didn’t seem like he was able to motivate there vets enough to keep his job. Those same vets were traded to Colorado and Dallas and have  seemed to find new life this year. So I’m not sure what to make of his time in Nashville but will give him a chance. It really comes down to what the no move players think and do. 
         One other comment I’ll make is for all the fan fare about our prospects, nothing has been proven yet. I’m excited for all of them but realistically they are a long way from saying our future is bright. Cross reference our prospects with Chicagos prospects. Look at all the picks they still have to make.  I bet Chicago s future is much brighter than ours and we are in same division. Hopefully Judd hits on all his picks an I’m wrong. Chicago is building a powerhouse.  We are doing Fletcher 2.0 . Young guns with old vets . It may or may not work. 

    • Like 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Yep Hynes is another Guerin buddy. A coaching change always seems to bring a spark regardless of who it is. Who knows how happy Kaprizov is or isn't here. I do know this. He has always been an elite player on an elite team and has always been on a winning path. This is a new experience for him and I doubt he is enjoying it. Kaprizov did not come over here to play for the Minnesota Wild. He had no choice in that he came over here to win a Stanley Cup and probably more than one. About the only thing not on his resume.  

    I always felt this was a stepping stone for him and now that he is experiencing the losing culture my guess is he is already looking towards the exit. His agent is going to make negotiations very difficult either way. 

    Teams will be coming to call you can bet on that but he would do himself a favor to get out of this funk and start carrying this team to keep his stock value up. 

    • Like 2
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    6 minutes ago, MacGyver said:

    I always felt this was a stepping stone for him and now that he is experiencing the losing culture my guess is he is already looking towards the exit. His agent is going to make negotiations very difficult either way. 

    What about his comment to Yurov: "I'm waiting for you?" That sounds like someone committed to the team. I think he wants it built into a juggernaut. 

    • Like 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Kaprisov bought the apartment in downtown Minneapolis last summer. Don’t know if this is any indication. On the other side if I would be him I would leave. And agree with Tony 100% that nothing will stop his request for trade after this season. Hard to say if he likes Minnesota or not but there is nothing to like about the team as it is now. And there is no indication that BG is capable of making team better. Each of his f..:ing moves so far are complete disaster 

    • Like 4
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    7 minutes ago, mnfaninnc said:

    What about his comment to Yurov: "I'm waiting for you?" That sounds like someone committed to the team. I think he wants it built into a juggernaut. 

    Perhaps your right. But that would equal Kaprizov dictating the roster lineup which I think Guerin would be perfectly willing to do if it kept him here. That is not a good way to run a team. In fact a very bad way. Prospects are prospects and until they step foot on the NHl ice you never know what you got. If Kaprizov himself don't step up soon you could say the NHL has caught up to him and he is just another damn good player on a mediocre team.  As he has already shown Kaprizov likes to let his agent do all the talking when the time comes. 

    Edited by MacGyver
    • Like 2
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Dean got the hook sooner than I expected.  Thought he had until Jan to right the ship.  
    I think what sink Dean was that it was becoming a national story (not 1-2 MN hockey writers and reusse) how badly Dean was getting out coached.  It was such common knowledge that it was hurting the Wild brand (Jersey sales, tickets, etc) and that gets Leo’s attention.  I think the whispers are getting louder about Guerin’s old core extensions and that got Guerin’s attention. Must change headline, said Guerin.
     

     I agree with prior post that this core will chew up coaches, and that’s probably why we get journeyman Hynes and not a bigger name.  Change should give core a boost for 10-15 games until this group goes full mojo again in February

     #never go full mojo

    Edited by Pewterschmidt
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    4 minutes ago, Pewterschmidt said:

     I agree with prior post that this core will chew up coaches, and that’s probably why we get journeyman Hynes and not a bigger name

    Going outside of the organization and not the interim route in season makes for very slim pickin's. I'd say that since Hynes and Guerin are familiar with each other, this may have been the next in line instead of Sully. Sadly for us, Sully didn't get fired.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    So, there was one more firing too, Bob Woods. What do you guys think about that?

    I'd say someone with more credibility needs to move into the position. Woods is a Boudreau confidant. Stevens, when he was here, had the room.

    • Like 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    It didn’t work for Fletcher. Who built a Stanley cup winner by drafting one 20 th overall per year? You believe what you want . Chicago is doing it right . We are not ! It was perfect time to accumulate high draft picks during buyouts by selling ufa s at deadline. Not grifting off fans and writing stories about things that are years away . Especially when a team in your division is already started to see there picks on ice and has tons more.  Prospects are nothing till they prove it in nhl. Bedard is better than Rossi . There young stud d man is already better than any  d prospect we have.  Every year we trot out a kid Chicago will have a better one 
     

    • Like 2
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    15 minutes ago, mnfaninnc said:

    Going outside of the organization and not the interim route in season makes for very slim pickin's. I'd say that since Hynes and Guerin are familiar with each other, this may have been the next in line instead of Sully. Sadly for us, Sully didn't get fired.

    Perhaps it could be that Hynes is a stop gap coach. I don't think that will be the case but who knows.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I just think if you hit right, that's how you build. Most of it is luck, but if you can hit 3 to 4 guys within a 3 year period, you have a pretty good chance of being a contender. By hitting, I don't mean a superstar, they just need to play a significant role for the team.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    1 minute ago, Up North Guy said:

    Perhaps it could be that Hynes is a stop gap coach. I don't think that will be the case but who knows.

    According to the Tenneseean, Trotz recommended Hynes for another shot, and he cleaned up a bunch of stuff for the Preds. I'm not sure what that was, but he was given 3 invitations in 4 years, and the year he missed, Forsberg was hurt for a good portion of it.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    So, the Blues are up next. It seems like a lot of guys are gripping their sticks too tight. There are 2 ways to loosen that up.

    1. Score a lot of goals with everyone getting into the act
    2. Having a boys will be boys game where the bell rings a lot and there are lots of majors handed out

    Chances of scoring a lot of goals on the Blues? Probably fairly small.

    Chances of finding a dance partner? Probably fairly good. 

    If the scoring doesn't come early, I'd suggest making good use of the time and start dropping the mitts! A total meltdown game isn't out of realm of possibilities. It will loosen everyone up. And, we've got crazy eyes who can lead us!

    • Haha 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Hynes?  They finally do something, and that’s the answer?  Was Bruce Boudreau busy? 

    I’m to the point where I don’t care about Kaprisov staying. We’ve done nothing with him.  We’re not doing anything with him anytime soon.  Guerin is botching moves left and right.  We’re trying to kick the can down the road, and we suck at it.  It’s like a drug addict “chasing the dragon.”  It’s over.  

    Fire Guerin.  Find a GM that knows what he’s doing and isn’t playing early 90s fantasy hockey. Trade Kaprisov for a haul, and anyone else we can (anyone Guerin didn’t inexplicably hand a freaking no-move clause).  Rip the bandaid off and rebuild this thing.  

    • Like 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I will be interesting to see what the new coaches approach is with line combos etc , if he just plays it safe and  mirrors the previous regime or if he needs to make a contrast .   

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    11 minutes ago, joebou15 said:

    Not true, but you can't do it it with a bunch of guys over 30 with zero flexibility.

    This is also true, unless those guys are just placeholders. Placeholders generally don't have 4 year contracts and designations though.

    • Like 2
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    2 hours ago, mnfaninnc said:

    I just can't imagine that this is all about #97.

     

    Minnesota fans and writers have some sort of fan PTSD due to all the Minnesota sports failures I think.  I don't think firing Evason has any thing to do with KK97 other than the fact that he didn't solve the 1st line.

    This is like problem #15 in the list of problems with the team for which Evason was fired.

    • Like 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites




    Join the conversation

    You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Guest
    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...