Jump to content
Hockey Wilderness
  • The Wild Need Marc-Andre Fleury To Have A Bounce Back Season


    Image courtesy of Matt Blewett-USA TODAY Sports
    Robert Brent

    The Minnesota Wild’s goaltending situation is one of the more fascinating storylines for the team entering the 2024-25 season. The team employs a legend (Marc-Andre Fleury), one of the top goaltending prospects in the world (Jesper Wallstedt), and a man who registered a .931 save percentage two years ago (Filip Gustavsson). 

    But despite having one of the league’s more intriguing situations, goaltending was one of Minnesota’s greatest weaknesses last season. Fleury had the worst season of his career statistically. Gustavsson took a step back. None of Minnesota’s three goalies even logged a save percentage over .900. 

    The failures in the crease have led to questions for the Wild entering next season. Is Jesper Wallstedt ready to take on more responsibility? Is there a possible trade involving Filip Gustavsson? 

    No matter what happens, Minnesota will need a big rebound season from their goalies. For the Wild to get right in the net, they’ll need a bounce-back season from Marc-Andre Fleury. 

    Fleury will play an important role in Minnesota’s goaltending battery

    At first glance, it’s concerning that the Wild will depend on a goaltender who turns 40 next season. However, Fleury is the most stable netminder of their goaltending trio.

    Gustavsson has become the subject of trade rumors since taking a step back last season. Regardless of how he performs this year, Gustavsson may not be playing in a Minnesota uniform by season’s end. Jesper Wallstedt is incredibly promising but has only played three NHL games so far and may require more seasoning in Iowa. Wallstedt and Gustavsson could play essential roles for the Wild, but they may also be part of some transactions or spend most of the year in the AHL to develop. 

    On the other hand, Fleury will be a part of the Wild’s goaltending picture. The NHL legend signed a one-year, $2.5 million contract last April, which is too much money to bury in the AHL without it counting against the cap. Fleury’s contract also carries a no-movement clause. The Wild could have moved Fleury last year, but Bill Guerin said the goaltender had earned the right to “call the shots.” Assuming Fleury still wants to stay in Minnesota, he isn’t going anywhere. Those conditions make him Minnesota’s only goaltender who is certain he will play in Forest Green for the entire season. If the Wild are going to turn around their goaltending fortunes, Fleury will have to be a significant factor.

    Statistical profile

    Let's look back before looking forward to determine whether Fleury can bounce back. Fleury’s 2023-24 season was the worst statistical year of his career, but how bad was it? Is there any reason to believe he can turn it around? 

    Fleury’s counting stats tell a bleak story. He logged a .895 save percentage, which was the worst of his career. He hasn’t dipped below .900 since he was 21, with a .898 save percentage in 2005-06. Fleury’s 2.98 goals against average represented his worst since 2016-17. However, comparing last season’s stats to one of the most decorated goaltending careers in NHL history may be unfair. 

    Still, Fleury’s statistics are even alarmingly lower than his first full season in Minnesota. In 2022-23, Fleury produced a .908 save percentage with a 2.85 goals-against average. Numbers like that would go a long way in delivering results for the Wild. Basic stats don’t always tell the whole story, though. Diving deeper into Fleury’s analytics forms a much more complete narrative.

    Marc-Andre Fleury’s traditional counting stats didn’t look good last year, but his advanced statistics don’t look much better. Fleury ranked towards the bottom of the league in several key measurements. 73 goalies played at least 10 NHL games last season. Among those 73 goalies, Fleury ranks in the bottom 10 considering all situations in goals saved above expected, save percentage above expected, goals against better than expected, and goaltending wins above replacement.

    Screenshot 2024-08-26 at 12.53.29 PM.png

     

    Screenshot 2024-08-26 at 12.54.03 PM.png

    Screenshot 2024-08-26 at 12.54.32 PM.png

    In many ways, The Wild had a disappointing 2023-24 season. We can attribute a lot of that to goaltending woes. As evidenced by the statistics, Fleury was one of the worst-performing goaltenders in the league, and Gustavsson had a similar or even worse season in many statistics. If Fleury can provide better results, it would go a long way in improving the Wild’s fortunes next season. But is there any reason to believe that can happen?

    Finding positives

    It’s easy to look at Fleury’s season last year as entirely negative, but there are reasons to believe he could turn it around. One of the most critical aspects of goaltending is restricting high-danger shots by limiting rebounds. Last year, Fleury was the best goaltender in the league at limiting rebounds, allowing a rebound every .04 save he made. If he can continue to control the puck the same way next year, it should lead to more positive outcomes. 

    Even more encouraging is when you look at Fleury’s statistics through a different lens. The advanced statistics we looked at before factored in all situations. You get a completely different result when you sort his outcomes for five-on-five. In even strength scenarios, Fleury has a positive rate in every statistic above.

    Screenshot 2024-08-26 at 12.55.17 PM.png

    Screenshot 2024-08-26 at 12.55.47 PM.png

    When considering his even-strength results alone, Fleury wasn’t a spectacular goalie last season but was essentially league-average. The Wild can work with that, considering that Minnesota’s old penalty kill cratered Fleury’s statistics drastically. While poor results on the penalty kill aren’t ideal, it’s also difficult to blame him entirely. 

    The Wild suffered several injuries last year, mainly to key defenders Jonas Brodin and Jared Spurgeon. It isn’t difficult to imagine a scenario where Minnesota’s penalty kill improves this year with a more stable environment. The Wild penalty kill ranked third last in the NHL last year, killing just 74.5% of their short-handed predicaments.

    Outlook For Marc-Andre Fleury’s 2024-25 Season

    Marc-Andre Fleury is different from the goaltender he once was. That’s okay; the Wild shouldn’t need him to be the player he was in his prime. Regardless of whether Fleury’s performance sinks or swims the season, they’ll have had more pressing issues. However, Fleury can play an important role. He has cemented his place on the team, and Minnesota will undoubtedly have to rely on him. 

    Fleury’s five-on-five numbers are solid despite not being spectacular. The Wild should have a much more stable defense this year. Last season, the blueline suffered many injuries that likely made work harder than necessary for the Wild’s goalies. Still, Fleury needs to play better if Minnesota will contend next season.

    Think you could write a story like this? Hockey Wilderness wants you to develop your voice, find an audience, and we'll pay you to do it. Just fill out this form.

    • Like 1
    • Confused 1

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    Featured Comments

    Hoping Fleury has a bounce back season at age 40 is ridiculous. Love the guy. He is a HOF'er but he is not the goalie he was and expected anything mor than slight decline is a recipe for disappointment.

    • Like 4
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Quote

    As evidenced by the statistics, Fleury was one of the worst-performing goaltenders in the league, and Gustavsson had a similar or even worse season in many statistics.

    Much of this article is wrong. Gustavsson was the better goalie last season, and is the one the Wild should be counting on for a bounce back year. If Gus has the season he's capable of, Fleury may not tally 30 starts.

    Gustavsson faced tougher competition last year and finished the season with better stats than fleury in many categories. Gus is entering his prime years while Fleury is fading. It would be nice if Fleury does better than the prior season, and that's possible with improved defensive play, but pinning hopes on goalies over 40 having bounce-back years is foolhardy at its core.

    • Like 6
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    If the season goes as well as the Wild can hope, they should get over 50 starts, perhaps 60+, for Gustavsson and Wallstedt combined.

    Fleury in a highly paid mentor role who is now a below average NHL goalie.

    • Like 5
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Fleury can still bounce around like a super ball, but he won't win you games.  The Wild need to manage 3-4 goals a game or at least limit penalties so goalies don't face too much grief.  

    Then again, expecting players like Hartman to play disciplined is probably barking up the wrong tree.

    • Haha 2
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    MAF’s career reminds me of one of my favorite golfers… Both burst onto the scene at a young age, making waves with big personalities. Both rose to the very pinnacle of their respective sports winning major championships. Most of all both are extremely entertaining. Both are destined for the hall of fame, well maybe not both. It’s going to be a long shot for John Daly to get there, but you never know. 

    • Haha 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    3 hours ago, Imyourhuckleberry said:

    If the season goes as well as the Wild can hope, they should get over 50 starts, perhaps 60+, for Gustavsson and Wallstedt combined.

    Fleury in a highly paid mentor role who is now a below average NHL goalie.

    Guerin said he's looking for 40-50 starts for MAF. (Shrug)

    • Haha 2
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    27 minutes ago, Burnt Toast said:

    MAF’s career reminds me of one of my favorite golfers… Both burst onto the scene at a young age, making waves with big personalities. Both rose to the very pinnacle of their respective sports winning major championships. Most of all both are extremely entertaining. Both are destined for the hall of fame, well maybe not both. It’s going to be a long shot for John Daly to get there, but you never know. 

    giphy.gif

    • Like 2
    • Haha 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    30 minutes ago, Willy the poor boy said:

    They need to let Wally get the majority of the starts in IA.. He needs to play...

    Completely agree. I think he'll likely get fewer than 20 starts at the NHL level this season, but I think Gustavsson should get more than 40 himself. If Fleury plays more than half of the games, it would be quite surprising to me. He played 40 last year, but after putting together a strong series of games periodically, he would then get beaten much more consistently.  He had an .878 save percentage in his final 10 games when they had him facing equally difficult matchups to Gus.

    Fleury built up his better stats earlier in the year because Gus was facing the difficult teams while Fleury wasn't getting as many. When they tried using Fleury as the 1A, he held up for a few games before getting beaten regularly.

    • Like 3
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I'm dreaming of the day our GM will know when it's the right time to let a player go.  He should watch what they do in Vegas.  Everyone loves MAF, that's not the issue.  The issue is we're trying to win, not have the best locker room.  

    • Like 8
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    4 hours ago, Willy the poor boy said:

    Guerin said he's looking for 40-50 starts for MAF. (Shrug)

    If this is what Guerin said you can probably bank on it happening. Fluery is the captain of team Billy's Boy's and a throw back to Billy's glory days. He will be given every opportunity to go out on a high note. So I guess coach Hynes has his marching orders on how many games Fluery needs to be in the crease. 

    • Like 2
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    1 hour ago, Outskated said:

    I'm dreaming of the day our GM will know when it's the right time to let a player go.

    Who has he let walk? There are more than a few as i think about it: parise, suter, koivu, stall, T-bot, fiala....and a bunch of bottom 6 and 3rd pair players.

    So what is the long term plan?  Is it about getting out the old stale veteran personalities and replacing them with salt-of-the-earth happy to be here types.   Ok, I can follow that then what's the second act?  Filling the top 6 with killers I hope (and I'm guessing Guerin would agree) so Ogzy and Hooz Nut are the first wave.  Let's go bro's!!  

    Edited by Pewterschmidt
    • Like 1
    • Thanks 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    3 minutes ago, MacGyver said:

    He will be given every opportunity to go out on a high note.

    He'll have at least 31 games with one in each arena on his farewell tour.

    • Like 2
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    2 hours ago, Outskated said:

    I'm dreaming of the day our GM will know when it's the right time to let a player go.

    Shooter is on record saying he doesn't really know much about goaltenders and goaltending. I assume that this meant he thinks they're weird. So, he thinks Fleury can do it.

    I disagree with that. I'm seeing a goalie who is small, still flexible but losing reflexes and having to guess more and more. That is not a recipe for a successful goalie this year, and it is definitely not a recipe for consistency. Good defense or not, it looks like he is on the downward slide which tends to get steeper once it's there. 

    • Like 3
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    15 hours ago, Pewterschmidt said:
    15 hours ago, MacGyver said:

    He will be given every opportunity to go out on a high note.

    He'll have at least 31 games with one in each arena on his farewell tour.

    I don't see that happening. If you value his send off more than winning, you lose the whole team and that's the type of thing that would have Kaprizov looking to sign elsewhere.

    Kaprizov might even like Fleury, but it's a results league, so Fleury would need to be clearly outplaying the other goalie options and I don't see that as highly likely given the way things have been trending the last 3 seasons where Fleury has been the best Wild goalie in exactly zero seasons.

    • Like 2
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Certainly is possible.  Add a little bulk to the team, some luck with solid, consistent defense, win a few more faceoffs, and play a more disciplined less penalty game.  If those elements are part of the Wild this season, even in his final year and tapering performance, 24-25 should be a better season. 

    • Like 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I believe Fleury will have a bounce back year of a sort.  He is obviously aging and his timing and quickness just isn't what it used to be.  He's a player who has had a HOF career with athletic, improbable saves and the ability that has carried him is fading a bit, but I think last year wasn't a clear indicator of how far he really has dropped off.

    The main caveat to Fleury bouncing back at all this season is having a mostly healthy team in front of him.  I know every team has injuries, but the players who did get injured often were expected to play key roles for the team.  The article mentions Spurgeon and Brodie because those are names people immediately attribute to defense.

    Quote

    The Wild suffered several injuries last year, mainly to key defenders Jonas Brodin and Jared Spurgeon. It isn’t difficult to imagine a scenario where Minnesota’s penalty kill improves this year with a more stable environment. The Wild penalty kill ranked third last in the NHL last year, killing just 74.5% of their short-handed predicaments.

    Having both out for significant portions of the season definitely didn't make us a better defensive team despite Faber's attempt at holding the fort together by playing half the game. The opposing team was able to break down our defense too often for high danger chances.  We couldn't force them into more difficult shots as often.  We weren't able to cover passing lanes as well.  Our team defense was porous and dysfunctional at best.

    There is more to it than just the defense though.  The forwards also contribute to defense. 

    Say what you want about Foligno, but having him out of the roster most of the season did not help our team defense or the PK.  Even when he did play, he did not seem like he was healthy.  A healthy Foligno doesn't just have the other team looking over their shoulder, it gives us a pretty good, disruptive defensive presence on the ice that no one else on the roster was able to match.  The closest comparable is Eriksson Ek's defense, but he's a little bit of a different style defender.

    Gaudreau being hobbled also hurt the team.  Gaudreau isn't much better than a 4th line option, but defensively he can contribute a bit.  A healthy Gaudreau is better than a Lettieri or a Luchini.  I'd also say he's probably better than Khusnutdinov, but I'm hoping to see more from Khusnutdinov this season where he really challenges and overtakes Gaudreau.  Defensively they both seem to be about equivalent, though I think Khusnutdinov's quickness will give him an edge once he becomes more acclimated to the NHL.  I'd also like to see him be used in PK situations more.  Point is, a challenge by Khusnutdinov should motivate Gaudreau to be a bit more aggressive, both of which helps us overall.

    Boldy was also hurt for a number of games.  I know top 6 offensive players tend not be thought of so much when it comes to defense, but Boldy has such good hand-eye coordination that he stops a fair amount of breakout passes with his stick.

    Why are I bringing all this up?  Because the Wild are heavily reliant on team defense, and as the pieces start to be missing and others are shuffled in, team defense suffered a lot last year - none of that helping Fleury or our PK.  Save percentage as whole in the NHL was lower last year and shooting percentages were up too.  That also didn't help.

    What I think will help is having people healthy more.  I think Trenin will help gives a bit of flexibility while being a bit more balance so there is less of a drop-off if a few players do get hurt for short intervals.  I also think Hynes will change up the system to something that will give the goaltenders a better chance to stop more picks.

    So yes, I do think Fleury will have a bit of a bounce back year, but I think it will be less of Fleury himself bouncing back and more the team helping him (and Gustavsson) be more successful by making the other team work harder for their shots than they had to do last year given that we could only put a shell of the team of the ice from the year prior.

    Edited by raithis
    Clerical error
    • Like 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Join the conversation

    You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Guest
    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...