Jump to content
Hockey Wilderness
  • Bill Guerin's Roster Construction Failed His Best Players


    Image courtesy of Brace Hemmelgam-USA Today Sports
    Matthew Smith

    The Minnesota Wild fizzled out in the first round of the playoffs again. We hate to see it happen, but the 2022-23 Wild ended with the enthusiasm of a week-old balloon. Rather than triumphantly building on the franchise's second-straight season of 100-plus points and a successful regular season, the team seemed to be fighting uphill for the entirety of their first-round matchup against the Dallas Stars.

    We will pick apart the corpse of another disappointing season, then have all summer to try and figure out what went wrong and why this team can’t seem to muster any playoff success.

    Some will blame the coaching staff for periphery decisions that would typically be inconsequential on a team good enough for a deep postseason run. And you wouldn't necessarily be wrong if you lay the blame on the overly-sensitive whistles operated by the referees. However, that might also loop back to coaching. Minnesota's excessively aggressive playstyle laid them at the mercy of the Stars' brutally efficient power play, which scored on more than a third of its opportunities.

    However, the blame doesn't lie with the players who make this team extraordinary and provide it with such a high ceiling. It hasn’t been hard to come across opinions from fans and experts proclaiming that Minnesota’s best players didn’t perform. But if you watched the games and aren’t ignoring every stat beyond goals and assists, there is a pretty clear picture that at least a couple of the premier players showed up and were let down by the tools they’ve been given.

    Kirill Kaprizov and Matt Boldy carry the burden of Minnesota's present and future. The offense was a problem against the Stars, but Kaprizov and Boldy weren’t the issue. Yes, Kapriov had only one goal and no assists, while Boldy had three assists and no goals. That's the first time both players had been in a slump like that all season. But that doesn’t tell the whole story.

    According to NHL.com, Boldy and Kaprizov led all skaters — not just the Wild — in shot attempts at even strength with 32 and 29, respectively, during the first round. They created more high-danger scoring chances than anyone not named Marcus Foligno, with seven for Kaprizov and five for Boldy, according to NaturalStatTrick.com. If no one is there to pass you the puck or often finish otherworldly plays the two created, how can you rack up many points? Any coach worth his salt will applaud the process over the results. We should too.

    We now know that Mats Zuccarello was playing with a groin injury, and it showed in his game. Joel Eriksson Ek was trying to play through a broken fibula and lasted only 19 seconds. Freddy Gaudreau often replaced Eriksson Ek as Boldy's center, and he had an abdominal issue that had been bothering him for months.

    That doesn’t dismiss or excuse why it became so otherworldly difficult for Minnesota's top wingers to get on the board. Putting the blame squarely on the players for that is a mistake, though. You see, it’s a problem that fans have seen and known about for years, and have been pounding for management to address for about as long.

    Of the top-10 scorers in the first round, four of them are centers. Two centers in the Stars lineup stand atop the rest for generating offense during the series — Roope Hintz and, surprisingly, Wyatt Johnson. The Stars' depth at center showed what a performing playoff team looks like. If you can stomach re-watching this latest first-round exit, look at what Roope Hintz did to the Wild:

    The gap in talent between Dallas and Wild's respective center depth can only be described as a chasm. Of the top-15 skaters in generating individual expected goals for totals, the two Wild centermen — a term used very loosely here — on the list are Ryan Hartman and the oft-maligned Sam Steel. Without Eriksson Ek, their depth down the middle looked more like a team contending for Connor Bedard than a Stanley Cup.

    Whatever the problem is, it seems to be keeping general manager Bill Guerin up at night. “The thing that bothered me is that there were reoccurring issues,” Guerin said in his postmortem press conference on Tuesday. “Did we reach our ultimate goal? We did not,” Guerin continued, “but this season is not a failure.”

    Another season without a playoff-round win is a disappointment, but most teams would be happy with the regular season performance. But the Wild faithful won’t be satisfied with that come next year. If Guerin is losing sleep, let’s hope he’s using that time to devise a solution to what ails this team. He owes it to his players, particularly the ones he counts on to carry his squad.

    Think you could write a story like this? Hockey Wilderness wants you to develop your voice, find an audience, and we'll pay you to do it. Just fill out this form.


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    Featured Comments

    Quote

    We now know that Mats Zuccarello was playing with a groin injury, and it showed in his game. 

    I don't think this was a new injury either. I believe I noticed it around January/February, he just didn't look right skating.  Groin injuries just linger, it takes a long time for them to heal. Hopefully he didn't do any more damage to it.  

    I also don't believe this is a reason for his downward spiral in productivity. When Kaprizov went out, he kind of disappeared after a couple of games. I really think he may have hit the wall of age, that undefeated wall that eventually gets everyone. 

    I wonder what a team would pay for a Zuccarello at $4m?

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Quote

    I wonder what a team would pay for a Zuccarello at $4m?

    Probably not many. Might have to let him play or buy him out.

    Painful to watch Jarvis last goal against NJ. Bats down a pass, chips it out, chases it down while he out-skates the defenseman he just stole the puck from and scores bar down.

    We'll keep saying Rossi is gonna pay off one day though, even though the point of the article is how the Wild lacked more talented support players. Jarvis has three goals this playoffs. He, Mercer and Lundell all with a handful of points this playoffs. These guys scoring more playoff points than the majority of Wild players. 21 year old players.

    • Like 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I understand we need at least one more high level center, with Ek back next year, but your sentence "Boldy and Kaprizov led all skaters — not just the Wild — in shot attempts at even strength with 32 and 29, respectively" kind of refutes your articls premise. Did they get these all on their own, without getting passes from other's? That's a lot of missed chances that fall on them to finish. Yes it would be nice to get others to get rebounds, if available, but that was not your point. If it was, then their stats would even be larger. 

    • Like 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    2 hours ago, Weestraw said:

    I understand we need at least one more high level center, with Ek back next year, but your sentence "Boldy and Kaprizov led all skaters — not just the Wild — in shot attempts at even strength with 32 and 29, respectively" kind of refutes your articls premise. Did they get these all on their own, without getting passes from other's? That's a lot of missed chances that fall on them to finish. Yes it would be nice to get others to get rebounds, if available, but that was not your point. If it was, then their stats would even be larger. 

    The more significant point is that sometimes puck luck doesn't go your way. So the team needs to be put in the best position to succeed. Kirill and Boldy performed well, but even then, it wasn't enough. So they need support if we want them to go further than they already have.

    They did their part, while those around them failed them.

    • Like 2
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    12 hours ago, Protec said:

    Painful to watch Jarvis last goal against NJ. Bats down a pass, chips it out, chases it down while he out-skates the defenseman he just stole the puck from and scores bar down.

    We'll keep saying Rossi is gonna pay off one day though, even though the point of the article is how the Wild lacked more talented support players. Jarvis has three goals this playoffs. He, Mercer and Lundell all with a handful of points this playoffs. These guys scoring more playoff points than the majority of Wild players. 21 year old players.

    I get that Jarvis and Mercer are producing right now, but they are also playing on the wing, not at center. Lundell also spent some time on the wing this season, but is predominantly a center. We need centers, not wings (though RHS forwards would be nice too).

    There seems to be 3 centers right around our 1st round pick slot. Nate Danielson, Calum Ritchie, Samuel Honzek. There's also a few in the 2nd round. This year's top 50 prospects are supposed to rival 2015 and 2005. I've heard comparisons to 2003 from others. We will have picks 52ish and 61ish from the 2nd round. I would recommend moving up from those picks. 

    Oliver Moore is another guy I'd be interested in, even though he's shorter. His game has a lot of speed and everyone will get to watch him with the Gophers next season.  He'll likely be gone by the time it's our turn to pick. All told, I'd like to come out of this draft with 2 top 50 selections that are centers. I'm also not opposed to trading for developed centers with no NHL track record. 

    Here's the key, Shooter's got to fix this. The positionless hockey strategy where we don't have enough depth at C works in the regular season. For the last 4 trips to the postseason, it has not worked and we've gotten owned down the middle. Gaudreau and Hartman have both overachieved their contracts but neither should be mistaken as a top 6C or, for that matter, a full time top 6 player. Steel is not a top 6 player either. We only have 3 of those. The solutions must come from cheap contracts, therefore, unproven, developed players who we take a swing at.

    Of the above, I've read from Dobber that Danielson is close to NHL ready. His floor is a 3rd line C. His scouting report reads as someone very friendly to our system. I don't know that I'd rush him, but at the very least, he could give Rossi a run for his money this coming season.  To me, though, Ritchie seems like the guy to target. While Honzek is listed as a C, some of the scouting suggests he will be a W.  

    • Like 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    8 hours ago, Matthew Smith said:

    The more significant point is that sometimes puck luck doesn't go your way. So the team needs to be put in the best position to succeed. Kirill and Boldy performed well, but even then, it wasn't enough. So they need support if we want them to go further than they already have.

    They did their part, while those around them failed them.

    This is exactly the same thing I noticed about Fiala last playoffs. Boldy set him up for some grade A chances that he sent sailing over the top of the net. This playoffs it was Kaprizov and Boldy and especially Zuccarello going high and wide.

    I would suggest with all of those chances, we've got to bury them! I think both players, Boldy and Kaprizov, will be kicking themselves this offseason because they didn't bury their chances.  For Boldy, I think he needs the 1st in the playoffs before he gets rolling, for Kaprizov, I expect him to have a very hard working offseason and for his accuracy to get even more elite. Missed chances like that do not sit well with elite players, especially those who want to win really badly. Both of these guys seem like those types of players. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Boston, Best Season Ever! Colorado, returning Cup Holders.

    Both out in the first round. The Wild were in the Central race until 2 weeks from the end?

    Game 1 against Dallas set the bar and the Wild could never get back to that level.

    Not sure it's Guerin, The coaching staff needs to be scrutinized.

    With the news that all these top players were injured or not performing at the highest level causes me to look at where were the changes made in the lineup and personnel to offset the damage?

    Iowa Wild coaching staff got broomed after failing to advance in Calder Cup.

    Maybe The MN Wild coaches should take notice.

    Looking forward to 2023-2024, Go Wild!!!

     

     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Join the conversation

    You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Guest
    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...